Either Rotten Tomatoes was destroying the film industry, or it didn’t matter much at all, writes The Ringer, noting competing storylines about the influence of the film review-aggregating web site.
But they’ve now performed a statistical deep dive to try to answer the question, and concluded that “The truth likely lies in the middle: Rotten Tomatoes wasn’t tanking the industry or single-handedly exposing that Baywatch was bad, but it wasn’t irrelevant, either.”
In fact, our analysis reveals that Rotten Tomatoes scores are reliably correlated with box office performance, especially for certain genres. But the aggregator’s influence may have been on the wane before the coronavirus struck, and it may matter less than ever in the present uncertain circumstances…
Our first finding is that the average Rotten Tomatoes critic score has increased over time. Maybe movies have improved — or at least grown closer to critics’ liking — or maybe the rise reflects changes in the makeup of Rotten Tomatoes’ pool of reviewers… Whatever the reason(s) for the increasing scores, there’s no evidence of greater negativity that could be turning off ticket buyers (which probably doesn’t displease Fandango). The site bestows a “Fresh” rating on any movie with a 60 percent score or higher, and the average movie now clears that threshold….
Action movie earnings are the least closely associated with review scores, maybe because when people just want to see stuff blow up, they’re willing to lower their standards in certain respects. Comedies and horror movies — particularly the latter — are far more consistent with the critical consensus. A perfectly scored action movie’s earnings might double its budget, but a perfectly scored comedy can quadruple its budget, while a perfectly scored horror flick can beat its budget by 10 or 20 times…
The mystery of most interest to studio execs is whether Rotten Tomatoes has strengthened the relationship between the critical consensus and box office performance, which also existed in the pre-internet age. The evidence suggests that the studios were a tad too intimidated in 2017… However, there are some signs that increased attention to the critical consensus may have affected whether movies’ earnings got out to fast or slow starts, even if it didn’t dramatically lower or raise their final ticket tallies.
of this story at Slashdot.
Source:: Slashdot